Phoenicians are long gone bro, I think he's talking about Maltese people. I haven't watched all of the video as I comment this.
👍 42026/09/22
@zillavaleYouTube
No wayyy! Thats so interesting. I need to hear Maltese next to a Maghrebi person speaking Arabic
👍 32026/09/22
@maisa5943YouTube
Map without palestine????
👍 02026/09/22
@geox8485YouTube
Yeah language can be entirely based on politics, like how Urdu and Hindi is mutually intelligible and essentially the same language but is officially separated because of the Pakistan and India beef…
Meanwhile several Chinese languages which aren’t mutually intelligible at all are officially considered dialects of the same language…
👍 72026/09/23
@Anthroad111YouTube
Factsssssssssss
👍 22026/09/23
@jamesmckenzie1517YouTube
It’s not Maghrebi !
It’s somewhere between Sicilian dialect of Italian and a Levantine pre-Arabic Semitic language.
👍 02026/09/23
@jeanmichelismondi7865YouTube
It's not arabic langage but semitic !
👍 02026/09/23
@masehoart7569YouTube
I began following a learn Maltese Youtubd account. Most native Arabic speakers commented it sounds Tunisian- one Tunisian who also speaks fluently Italian could understand it all. Maltese developed from
Siculo-Arabic / the Arabic spoken in Sicily.
👍 12026/09/23
@zillavaleYouTube
And Danish, Swedish and Norwegian are almost mutually intelligble but they fought wars to have the status of their language be separate
👍 02026/09/23
@terrymuck6642YouTube
The english alphabet and writing is that Arabic Mostly the Arab slaves were Arabised the Black Europeans dissapeared most of them were Moors who moved into What is now known as Europe.
👍 02026/09/23
@generalnguyenngocloan1700YouTube
So, millions of Americans speak English who aren’t English and don’t consider themselves English.
👍 12026/09/24
@avicennatheconqueror7956YouTube
That’s simply false, first Arabic is a Semitic language that existed in the levant, actually the oldest evidence for Arabic is from the levant so there’s no such thing as pre Arabic levant, second Maltese sounds nothing like any Semitic language other than Arabic, it doesn’t sound like Aramaic or any Canaanite language
Third the history of Maltese is well documented it developed out of Sicilian Arabic (not Italian) which itself developed out Tunisian Arabic, since the Aghlabids that ruled Sicily for two hundred years we’re doing so from their seat in Tunisia
and finally Maltese sounds closest to Tunisian and has very similar vocabulary to it, stop pretending otherwise, Maltese is Tunisian Arabic with Italian words
👍 02026/09/26
@avicennatheconqueror7956YouTube
It developed out of Arabic, it’s Arabic, cry harder
Comments
15Log in to comment.
Meanwhile several Chinese languages which aren’t mutually intelligible at all are officially considered dialects of the same language…
It’s somewhere between Sicilian dialect of Italian and a Levantine pre-Arabic Semitic language.
Siculo-Arabic / the Arabic spoken in Sicily.
Third the history of Maltese is well documented it developed out of Sicilian Arabic (not Italian) which itself developed out Tunisian Arabic, since the Aghlabids that ruled Sicily for two hundred years we’re doing so from their seat in Tunisia
and finally Maltese sounds closest to Tunisian and has very similar vocabulary to it, stop pretending otherwise, Maltese is Tunisian Arabic with Italian words