Wish Has a HUGE Villain Problem #movie #animation #disney #hexed #wish

U got a point tho

He never wanted to he evil until Asha anyways

So.... I completely agree with you.

Like imagine someone's wish was for violence and death and arson.

Bacon Guys review of this movie also mentions this!

He which the left path

Oh nooo the guy who grants our wishes because he wants to isn't granting all of them. Oh nooooo he isn't giving us everything we want when we want it even though sometimes our wishes are contradictory to each other or sometimes downright dangerous. Oh nooooooooooo the king who's job it is to make our lives good is actually governing us instead of just doing what we want him to do

Magnifico is a bad person, and for those of you who call him the hero is all things considered “Snow White, Cinderella, and Aurora are weak, Ariel should not give up her voice for a man, Belle has Stockholm Syndrome, Aladdin’s a gold digger and Jasmine’s ungrateful, etc” all over again. He’s evil because he chooses to be bad, not from trauma but because he wants power, which is one of the main reasons he refuses to grant wishes. And don’t like people view Asha as the villain. She doesn’t want all the wishes granted, her main concern is that the king makes it “so people forget the most special part of themselves.” And for her becoming a fairy godmother, the fairy godmother doesn’t exactly grant wishes, but mainly helps people along the way. This movie was not a terrible movie like you think it is, and there is a video explaining why Magnifico was always a bad person

Personally? I don't mind giving my wish away for free home and no taxes and security

Asha literally is the reason Peter Pan is a thing and the original story he is not good guy hook is mean Asha created the deeply twisted and immoral guy that as the original book says “thins them out” when they grow up heavily implying he kills them so yeah I’d say magnifico thinks ahead

I get what you mean. He was at most misguided and Asha’s motivation can be sort of understood but comes off pretty vague and kind of selfish in practice (mostly just a meh execution of her character)

Exactly like what if one of the civilians wanted world domination or become a prolific murderer or something does Asha want that to happen

I think the book was the villain. Once he touched it, he started becoming more insane and became a bully/corrupt to his people

To be fair, the grandpa’s wish was very vague. He could’ve done anything with that wish, and making someone forget an unachievable goal isn’t malicious in any way if it means they won’t feel the pain of not achieving their wish.

HE WAS RIGHT and they punished him for it lol

Also if people didn’t have the wishes they could focus on other more important things like jobs

What if someone wants to start another world war also like you said they new what they were getting themselves into if you sign a contract but it’s bad you should not complain you should know what your getting yourself into also idk have you seen the people they look pretty happy it’s not an issue😊

I agree with you 100%. Plus what if someone wish for something bad like maybe kill someone? Since he has the power to grant wished, it's his power and has the right to deny a bad wish, in which I hope so if someone wanted me dead. Yes someone wish could destroy another person wish. Also he right about wished also helping the kingdom, not ruin it.

I think the idea that you live for free in Rosas is a metaphor. There are always taxes to pay, and in this case the main tax is the wish. And the logic is this: You give me your wish and I let you live in my kingdom

He lets you live here for free and he doesn’t even charge you rent!

All because of Asha’s assumption King Magnifico became the villain?🤔🤨

I agree he was right he was just afraid of what the wishes would become if he granted them all at ounce.

You say that he lets them live here for free but you forgot to add that he DON’T EVEN CHARGE THEM RENT! (Seriously these songs were killing me).

Hes potential was wasted

Ever since the first trailer i thought he was right and the story would be about careful what you wish for, where she wouldn't listen and thus cause the problem, that couldn't be fixed until she grew and learned WHY it's not as simple as granting every wish.

I hate how ahsa made him Evil he was such a good person until asha ruin everything and been a bosy person

Honestly I have to agree with you. Asha's motivation as a main character is half baked at best. Well more like under baked....I liked Asha but she sucks as a main "hero" character..It's cause her and her friends are NOT heros..Magnifico was right! And he wasn't really an evil guy until they shoved in the "twist" villain bullshit. Wish is one of the worst Disney movies to days. 0.1/10.. Magnifico is the best character..I don't fully hate wish but I'm very disappointed in it, especially since it was Supposed to celebrate Disney's 100th Anniversary as a studio which it failed..

Disney's Once Upon a Studio short does that WAY better in the 10 or so minutes and pays tribute to all it's amazing characters... And it's heartwarming to boot.. But unfortunately Disney has yet to make anything that lives up to that amazing short

they force him to be a villain 😂

Fully in agreement with you, we could have easily had a “be careful what you wish for” story (especially in this age of hyper indulgence) and have the protagonist grow into a more mature and wise person, instead we have a story of “king bad because we don’t get every little thing we want” despite living in a kingdom with little crime, no poverty and no taxes (and from the look of it, no army as all the “guards” are just magic suits of armor, like the king literally gets his own horse when he could have made someone get Asha instead)