YalaTubeEG

Whalefall Movie: Can a Sperm Whale Really Swallow a Human?

848 views2026/10/15
Maddie Massy
Maddie Massy
YouTube Channel
▶ Open source
848 views · 2026/10/15

Could a sperm whale really swallow a human? This nightmare scenario (seriously, can you imagine anything worse) is the plot of the new movie Whalefall...

Refs:
American Museum of Natural History, 2017, ‘The Squid and the Whale: Evidence for an Epic Encounter’

Daniel Kraus, 2023, ‘Whalefall’

Popular Science, 2026, ‘Could a whale really swallow a human? We asked a biologist.’

Royal Society of Chemistry, 2017, ‘The acid (bath) test’

Tech Times, 2026, ‘Inside Whalefall: Sperm Whale Biology Makes Its Premise More Terrifying’

#whalefall #whalefallmovie #deepsea #spermwhale #STEM

Comments

125

Log in to comment.

@hlumelomrali4081
@hlumelomrali4081YouTube
The sperm whale has a really large throat? Yeah I’m not mature enough for this short . See you in the next one my guy
👍 102026/10/15
@unseenlie
@unseenlieYouTube
Bro it's a fucking whale 💔
👍 62026/10/16
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
😂 I knew at least one person would say this…
👍 52026/10/16
@WoofyMD
@WoofyMDYouTube
How the heck can you make an entite movie on that stuff? 15 minutes okay sure a short story, but a full movie?
👍 6242026/10/16
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
A lot happens! It’s based on a novel, following the scuba diver as he tries to survive. He has to survive in different areas of the whale and escape at the end of the
👍 1562026/10/16
@matthewhartweger9095
@matthewhartweger9095YouTube
​@maddiemassy CIA got her ass before she could finish 🥀
👍 02026/10/16
@MrNimbus420
@MrNimbus420YouTube
@maddiemassy This happens too on monkey island and I think something like this happens in the bible.
👍 02026/10/16
@theunknownunknowns256
@theunknownunknowns256YouTube
Humans as bi-catch, more of the bottom trawling lot should experience this.
👍 12026/10/16
@timtim8468
@timtim8468YouTube
It's a biblical story, symbolic, yikes!
👍 12026/10/16
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
Well said!
👍 02026/10/17
@Morrisgrantis
@MorrisgrantisYouTube
Seek help
👍 22026/10/17
@kyanartz
@kyanartzYouTube
Well yeah since they usually hunt bigger animal like giant squid thats why they have bigger throat then any other kind of whale, since they arent a filter feeder!
(I know you trynna make freaky joke)
👍 12026/10/18
@JacobCouch-j5u
@JacobCouch-j5uYouTube
There’s a lot more to it the just the whale scene
👍 12026/10/18
@JC-KillShot2
@JC-KillShot2YouTube
Awesome video! There is also somewhat recent footage of a sperm whale coming back up with a giant squid still in its mouth
👍 32026/10/18
@ahsoka_polo
@ahsoka_poloYouTube
The sperm whale would spit out humans too.
👍 82026/10/18
@TheBlackDragonVenom
@TheBlackDragonVenomYouTube
Ok, so Im not crazy, I thought this seemed unlikely, I appreciate your evidence? Proof? Ah whatever, cool short and very helpful!
👍 02026/10/18
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
Happy to help 🌟 I’ve got more shorts about other aspects of the movie too!
👍 12026/10/19
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
Wow really? Where can I see the footage? 😮
👍 02026/10/19
@Unga-bunga6761
@Unga-bunga6761YouTube
@Morrisgrantis it’s a joke
👍 02026/10/19
@44caIiberIoveletter
@44caIiberIoveletterYouTube
a good portion of the movie is flashbacks of his father and him just panicking lmao
👍 52026/10/19
@Cutie_River
@Cutie_RiverYouTube
its entirely impossible with would happen tho because giant squids live so far down in the ocean, its a 1 hour dive to get to their depth about, and a human would be instantly crushed if they free dived to that depth.
👍 1082026/10/19
@joyceshiver6622
@joyceshiver6622YouTube
Does it poop him out?!
👍 02026/10/20
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
In the movie, he dives only a few metres down, but the giant squid has come up close to the surface
👍 162026/10/20
@HerbertThePervert_Offical
@HerbertThePervert_OfficalYouTube
@maddiemassy still impossible since The waters surface is to hot for them
👍 42026/10/20
@joegraysonback5891
@joegraysonback5891YouTube
??? No? They come up to the surface at night
👍 52026/10/20
@McSmokeys
@McSmokeysYouTube
Who named this whale? 🤔🤣
👍 02026/10/20
@HerbertThePervert_Offical
@HerbertThePervert_OfficalYouTube
@j@joegraysonback5891 No? And even if it’s day time when he gets eaten.please use your magic rectangle
👍 02026/10/20
@DRAGONfinger-k6i
@DRAGONfinger-k6iYouTube
Bro this movie trailer made me so Clostiphobic😰😰😰
👍 02026/10/20
@sidneyswerissen3910
@sidneyswerissen3910YouTube
Well .. there is a video of a spermwhale eating a giant squid !!
👍 12026/10/20
@hankhammer869
@hankhammer869YouTube
Even if you survived the immediate encounter, you'd die of the bends in sudden pressure difference in either diving or resurfacing.
👍 12026/10/20
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
Very good point!
👍 02026/10/20
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
The whale would need to stay near the surface for you to have a chance
👍 12026/10/20
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
I’ve seen this on Shorts a few times but having a hard time verifying it or finding the original!
👍 02026/10/20
@brizayden
@brizaydenYouTube
Like a child, but not an adult...
👍 02026/10/20
@Cutie_River
@Cutie_RiverYouTube
@joegraysonback5891the pressure at the surface would kill tjem, that’s physically impossible
👍 42026/10/20
@Fat_frog_in_space
@Fat_frog_in_spaceYouTube
Bro I thought I was safe from Ocean horror movies with like jaws But they are it's whales like near where I live!!!!
👍 02026/10/20
@lettuceburger123
@lettuceburger123YouTube
"its throat is much larger" bet.
👍 12026/10/20
@WoFArtByYoursTruly
@WoFArtByYoursTrulyYouTube
Book name?
👍 02026/10/20
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
Whalefall also!
👍 02026/10/21
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
He is a teenager so perhaps still quite small…
👍 02026/10/21
@Austin-z7z
@Austin-z7zYouTube
This actually happened though,im not sure if the movie is based in the same story,but saw it on the news and all over YouTube like a week after it happened. Im pretty sure the guy survived,I dont remember if it was a sperms whale or not,but if I remember correctly,the guy was going to the surface and at the same time a whale was going to the surface and unintentionally swallowed him,im also pretty sure he was in there for a few hours,I think he only survived because he had his scuba tank mostly full. I dont think it was too recent,it may have been early this year or last year.
👍 12026/10/21
@Austin-z7z
@Austin-z7zYouTube
Wait no,I did some research. My memories of the story and what I know about the movie were merging. It was a humpback whale that swallowed a kayaker for a few seconds before spitting him out in 2025
👍 02026/10/21
@stiltmansstilt1014
@stiltmansstilt1014YouTube
Didnt they just find a sperm whale eatIng a giant squid like last yr? Im pretty sure it's real. Ive seen it a bunch of times
👍 02026/10/21
@Zerathina
@ZerathinaYouTube
So it’s technically possible, but it would never happen. And if it ever did, the whale’s first stomach would crush and grind you into powder so you wouldn’t experience anything beyond suffocation and crushing
👍 112026/10/21
@DarrenWard-e7s
@DarrenWard-e7sYouTube
You have a ton of pressurised air on your back. I think if you're in that terrible terrifying situation, you release the full pressure of your scuba gear. In the very least, it would probably encourage vomiting
👍 32026/10/21
@SFSplayer-yay
@SFSplayer-yayYouTube
also, don’t sperm whales have like a bunch of scratches on them and don’t giant squid have like little teeth on their suction cups or something
👍 02026/10/21
@FirstMilkCookiesmilkmama
@FirstMilkCookiesmilkmamaYouTube
Let's just hope this isn't another jaws situation and sperm whales don't get horribly misunderstood
👍 2072026/10/21
@kshenk17
@kshenk17YouTube
yeah so did we not learn our lesson with Jaws? aquatic life doesn’t need any more enemies…
👍 392026/10/22
@JoshuaCurtis-f4y
@JoshuaCurtis-f4yYouTube
Have seen a video where a sperm whale eats a giant squid but it was dead.
👍 12026/10/22
@Smencer
@SmencerYouTube
Director really said, let's take Jaws and make is as MID as possible
👍 182026/10/22
@modernlucas3
@modernlucas3YouTube
Don't worry, Jay is a potato so he'll just slip out
👍 02026/10/22
@Baileysprunki
@BaileysprunkiYouTube
Did he made a town inside the whale?..
👍 12026/10/22
@angrykatshere
@angrykatshereYouTube
I think it's a bit more unlikely
Stereotypically whales don't come off as frightening as sharks do (sharp teeth, fast movements, menacing from some angles). Sperm whales, or whales in general, are perceived very nurturing due to how famous their calm interactions with humans and their close relationships with kin.
Also, your average person that interacts with sperm whales is far fewer than the average person that interacts with sharks
The people who will act in malicious intent against sperm whales 9 out of 10 times was going to do it, with or without this movie (poachers of whales etc).

I would also like to think we are faster to debunk nonsense information than before due to widespread social media use.

In the end, if a person lets a movie impact their view of animal, then it says more about them. Whale protection effort is fairly high, though not equally practiced across the world.

Also, whales have been truly beloved for a long time. First non human sound to be put on that record thing that got send into space (for if life out somewhere else in space found it) was the recorded whale calls. Not sure if it's sperm or blue whale though. Close enough for the day to day person.
👍 132026/10/22
@gabriellazaro-f2v
@gabriellazaro-f2vYouTube
I love how he just somehow found the giant squid near the surface
👍 102026/10/22
@TravisMckay-s6p
@TravisMckay-s6pYouTube
But it’s based off a true story
👍 02026/10/22
@Samzilla2000
@Samzilla2000YouTube
How do we know that squids aren’t attacking whales? I always wondered the cookie cutter fish just takes a piece of flesh off of sharks and crap if I was a squid and I saw a whale, that’ll be a lot of like food just like bite it three times and then swim away.
👍 02026/10/22
@shades.of.h3r
@shades.of.h3rYouTube
I just watched an episode of this on Octonauts
👍 02026/10/22
@Ulthane-40k
@Ulthane-40kYouTube
Theres actually events of ppl getting eaten by whales by accident
👍 02026/10/22
@PaintballGargoyle
@PaintballGargoyleYouTube
If the person did not have a scuba tank on it is theoretically possible. But they also upped the whales size substantially for the movie lore.

The movie also had to keep Pg-13 rating so alot of the story is ommitted
👍 02026/10/22
@FoxiStevenYo
@FoxiStevenYoYouTube
Let me dress up as a seagull real quick
👍 02026/10/22
@angerskarin9222
@angerskarin9222YouTube
Giant squid live only about 1km under water, the only one we seen at the surface were already dead, those whale dont hunt in that shallow water.
👍 02026/10/23
@emmauu5156
@emmauu5156YouTube
bro learned shit from pinocchio
👍 12026/10/23
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
What is Octonauts?
👍 02026/10/23
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
It’s a good question! I doubt the squid would be trying to eat the whale though - it’s so different and vastly bigger than their usual prey.
👍 02026/10/23
@Ottermint
@OttermintYouTube
New free unlocked attacked by a whale or giant squid
👍 02026/10/23
@kerrydouce9200
@kerrydouce9200YouTube
The fact that we know at least one blue whale has sucked in a diver and a person on a kayak when a blue whales have been catching a big ball of small fish means it's possible it spat them out at least 😂😂
👍 02026/10/23
@unregisteredpotato
@unregisteredpotatoYouTube
wasn't there a guy who was swallowed by a whale once and got spitted out later?
👍 02026/10/23
@meirshomer4464
@meirshomer4464YouTube
It’s not even technically possible… a relatively normal sized human in scuba gear could never fit through a sperm whales throat. Also if they somehow were about the 100 ft length required to fit a scuba diver through its throat (largest ever recorded with any evidence was about 68 ft and the average fully grown adult male is about 52 ft), the scuba diver would not survive more than about a minute due to being melted by its stomach acids, crushed by its stomach, and crushed by the pressure change of it diving down. It is literally impossible to be swallowed unless we somehow have missed a sperm whale 1.5 times the size of the largest ever recorded.
👍 12026/10/23
@Kingoldntired
@KingoldntiredYouTube
No offense. But there was a lot of explaining going on after announcing they eat GIANT SQUIDs. Why would a smaller, human being not be able to fit down it's mouth/throat/gut in that case of course anything could hypothetical fit that's smaller than a GIANT SQUID
👍 12026/10/23
@Furyofthefallencharm
@FuryofthefallencharmYouTube
Oh hell, no
👍 02026/10/24
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
Good question! I would say humans are stiffer and less flexible - we’re bony while the squid is soft. So it’s a bit different!
👍 02026/10/24
@IndigoDoesStuff
@IndigoDoesStuffYouTube
Whales don’t eat humans and giant squid live way down in the ocean
👍 02026/10/25
@OllieTheSillyBilly
@OllieTheSillyBillyYouTube
One of the only problems I have with this movie is where this is set. Jay is LITERALLY just off the coast and barely underwater. Sperm whales dive deep into the twilight zone to hunt squid which is why we have never witnessed it, so it is almost impossible for this to happen just in a scuba dive.


Edit: When giant squids run away from whales, their defense mechanism is ink, and if they know they can just outlast the Sperm whales breath, I feel like the squid would dive deeper, not up to where Jay was.


Edit 2: I know it's just a movie and I bet it's great! I just wanted to point out something I saw
👍 2472026/10/25
@DonaldPerkins-p7i
@DonaldPerkins-p7iYouTube
It's happened before
👍 02026/10/25
@TheDragonborn_Knight
@TheDragonborn_KnightYouTube
There is a true story of a guy on a whaling boat who got swallowed by a sperm whale after falling off the boat while capturing the whale. They thought he had been killed by sharks but when they cought the whale, he was inside.
👍 02026/10/25
@RagingTyrannosaur
@RagingTyrannosaurYouTube
Was he alive or dead? (I assume dead, but who knows)
👍 02026/10/25
@RagingTyrannosaur
@RagingTyrannosaurYouTube
Squids don't have bones
👍 02026/10/25
@wendigowithaninternetconne9594
@wendigowithaninternetconne9594YouTube
THATS SO HOT I DIDNT KNOW IT WAS POSSIBLE
👍 02026/10/25
@QockNobblr
@QockNobblrYouTube
You would die of chemical burns from the stomach acid, or from being crushed by its digestive tract contracting. If you're lucky, you get lodged in the throat and die of asphyxiation. If you're unlucky, you'll literally be digested alive.
👍 02026/10/25
@RyenNekona
@RyenNekonaYouTube
Or a certain old man and his sentient wooden creation with a long nose
👍 12026/10/25
@yogabbagaby32
@yogabbagaby32YouTube
Omg just watched the movie. Probably one of the worst movies I’ve watched in a long time. Guy had major daddy issues
👍 02026/10/25
@TheDragonborn_Knight
@TheDragonborn_KnightYouTube
@RagingTyrannosaur he was alive but soon died after because of it.
👍 02026/10/25
@RagingTyrannosaur
@RagingTyrannosaurYouTube
​@TheDragonborn_Knight oh, that's sad. Rip
👍 02026/10/25
@enriconogueira-s5e
@enriconogueira-s5eYouTube
OH MY GOD FINALLY SOMEONE UNDERSTANDS BASIC CETACEAN DIETS!!!! Thank you!!!
👍 72026/10/25
@user-fi9pl5ck8r
@user-fi9pl5ck8rYouTube
It’s swallowing a squid 5x the humans size. It’s common sense that it’s a yes
👍 02026/10/25
@CelestialHunter-
@CelestialHunter-YouTube
Can a human swallow whale sperm?
👍 02026/10/25
@alexanderchristopher6237
@alexanderchristopher6237YouTube
Jaws was a massive hit so of course we will make more aquatic monsters based on sea creatures we don’t fully get.
👍 12026/10/25
@kshenk17
@kshenk17YouTube
@alexanderchristopher6237it’s really disgusting
👍 02026/10/25
@quiteslayer4067
@quiteslayer4067YouTube
Same thing happened with a humpback once. Was in Alaska, and was on the news and everything.
👍 02026/10/26
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
Squid are softer and easier to bend/compress than a human though…
👍 02026/10/26
@Moorwalk
@MoorwalkYouTube
Whalefall is actually an effective thriller that really feels claustrophobic. Jaws doesn’t have much to offer anymore.
👍 12026/10/26
@PainterMan87
@PainterMan87YouTube
The answer is no. Sperm whale esophagus is at the most 12in in diameter. A fully grown man wearing a scuba tank would not fit at all.
👍 12026/10/26
@TheMatMan-q8z
@TheMatMan-q8zYouTube
I know this sounds stupid but what if the squid couldve been blind and swam randomly up and just zig zag on the surface but yeah this is highly unlikely
👍 12026/10/26
@timetogames-kx5me
@timetogames-kx5meYouTube
im too stupid to not laught at words sperm whale
👍 02026/10/26
@Smencer
@SmencerYouTube
@MoorwalkIt was made in 1975... so yes, it is not going to be as good as modern movies...
👍 02026/10/26
@BrickSteppers
@BrickSteppersYouTube
There is a video of a spermwhale swallowing a giant squid (i'm like 99% sure it aint AI)
👍 02026/10/26
@IChoose_Me
@IChoose_MeYouTube
Isn't this based on the Bible story of Jona?
👍 02026/10/26
@KingT-Crown
@KingT-CrownYouTube
Maybe the squid gets their ahh so bad they forgot to use their ability
👍 02026/10/27
@JamesDavies-c7k
@JamesDavies-c7kYouTube
Who cares it’s a movie breh
👍 12026/10/27
@michaelbuick6995
@michaelbuick6995YouTube
Squid don't have bones. Anatomically, a whale just couldn't fit an adult man down it's throat if it tried.
👍 02026/10/27
@michaelbuick6995
@michaelbuick6995YouTube
That's just an old story. Not only is it impossible it was actually debunked by the crew of the ship.
👍 12026/10/27
@michaelbuick6995
@michaelbuick6995YouTube
That's happened a few times where a baleen whale has engulfed a diver (and in one photo a very surprised sealion). But they were in its mouth for about 2 seconds before it spat them out. The real danger here is drowning but as far as I know no one has ever died. The whale feels something is wrong immediately and out you go.
👍 02026/10/27
@tokyo4611
@tokyo4611YouTube
j'ai vu le film au cgr se matin c'était génial certains passages sont vraiment flippant
👍 02026/10/27
@Sylvanianbunny-d3t
@Sylvanianbunny-d3tYouTube
My friend read the book she said it was very interesting!
👍 02026/10/27
@JerometheRooster
@JerometheRoosterYouTube
This has happened before irl MrBallen has a video on it
👍 02026/10/28
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
I loved it too!
👍 02026/10/28
@SDeww
@SDewwYouTube
just listening to her made me dumber.
👍 02026/10/28
@hamwithcheese586
@hamwithcheese586YouTube
There are stories of sailors being swallowed by whales and surviving from America back when whale hunting was common.
👍 02026/10/28
@comeondowntosouthpark
@comeondowntosouthparkYouTube
Whats the geekbar situation inside a whale
👍 02026/10/28
@Kingston-t7g
@Kingston-t7gYouTube
That sounds really jaws
👍 02026/10/30
@derekeuchner1800
@derekeuchner1800YouTube
I was just watching a short where a guy was "swallowed" by a baleen whale. The guy apparently jumped into the water literally as the whale was scooping its way through. It freaked out, the guy freaked out, and he was spit out. 😂
👍 02026/10/30
@arc7375
@arc7375YouTube
It was a humpback whale. And it didn’t swallow him. It took a mouthful of water with the intention to filter it out and swallow the fish. It didn’t swallow anything. It felt a man in its mouth, and immediately spat him out.
👍 02026/10/30
@arc7375
@arc7375YouTube
No whale has ever swallowed a man. Ever.

A humpback whale once took a mouthful of water, to filter it out and eat the trapped fish. The man was in that water. So the whale spat him out immediately.

He wasn’t swallowed. The whale captured him in its mouth by accident, and immediately spat him out.

It’s physically impossible for any whale to swallow an adult human.
👍 02026/10/30
@arc7375
@arc7375YouTube
A squid is long but slender. And has no bones. And sperm whales eat via suction feeling. Like slurping a single spaghetto.

A human is too dense and bony. It can’t be swallowed.
👍 22026/10/30
@unregisteredpotato
@unregisteredpotatoYouTube
​@arc7375 yea that was the guy i was thinking of
👍 02026/10/30
@psychedpanda3333
@psychedpanda3333YouTube
How far would you have to dive to see this
👍 02026/10/30
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
Giant squid are typically found at 300-1000m (way further than a human can go), whilst sperm whales come to the surface. The idea in the movie is that the squid comes up way further than normal as it’s fleeing the whale
👍 12026/10/31
@psychedpanda3333
@psychedpanda3333YouTube
@maddiemassyso it’s not realistic or could a giant squid actually come up that high
👍 02026/10/31
@nassermohamed3545
@nassermohamed3545YouTube
I watched it but it’s was lowkey boring
👍 02026/10/31
@DC-bp8sx
@DC-bp8sxYouTube
There’s a guy who was on a paddle board and a giant squid came up and grabbed his board. Wasn’t very deep either, maybe 50-70 metres offshore.
He even drags it to shore it was that close to shore.
It was dying and came up.
They tend to do that when they are sick, they come to the surface.
Could happen if a sperm whale chased one to shallow waters. There’s videos of a sperm whale and their calf in pretty shallow waters outrunning killer whales I believe.
👍 22026/10/31
@arc7375
@arc7375YouTube
No it hasn’t.
👍 02026/11/02
@arc7375
@arc7375YouTube
Fake story. It never happened.
👍 12026/11/02
@nychris2258
@nychris2258YouTube
Sure but Sperm Whales hunt Giant Squid like 2000 meters below the surface and near Antarctica...
👍 02026/11/02
@karlepaul6632
@karlepaul6632YouTube
Plus a baleen whale doesn't eat squid
👍 12026/11/17
@maddiemassy
@maddiemassyYouTube
Sperm whales are toothed whales, not baleen whales 👍
👍 02026/11/17