"You're A Long Way From Home, Private." #bandofbrothes #movie

Doc can say anything and fears nothing because no one shoots at doc for free

When knowing the amount of morphine already given can either save or kill the patient, the medic has a good reason to yell at them.

Damn good quote

Yes

That's why there is a policy that each empty syringe is pinned to the uniform. So they don't need to remember.

They were taught in basic training for rendering first aid to pin the syringe on the jacket so you could tell how much had been administered. Not doing this was a rookie mistake.

​@amaldonado484 3 Morphines.... He just not survived he felt calm along the way to hospital 😂

​@osmolindqvist1567Except that both Winters and Welsh were veteran officers who'd been part of the company/battalion since it was first created including both of the airborne drops into Normandy and the Netherlands. That's why Doc Roe was angry, he needed to know how much morphine Heyliger had received so he wouldn't accidentally kill him but didn't because in the heat of the moment the two officers who both should have known better made a dumb mistake with not saving the empty morphine sticks.

You can't be serious right? He's the medic. If anyone has the right to be pissed about that it's him, and the military recognises that. How many painkillers you give a guy matters if they want to save the guy. How will the medic know if he can administer more anaesthetic or other medication if you tell him you don't know how much anaesthetic the patient was already given? And from the sounds of it they weren't supposed to give that much morphine

While in Indian military medical officer don't treat according to rank officer get good attention while OR don't

Yeah. He died in 2001 shortly after the TV show started

​@andrewgeissler8887well it was a full 10 episodes after all

I'd be more humbled than butthurt. The doc is absolutely right, after all.

NERD!!!!!!

​@joelsansbury90 you got that right!

This is a really nice reference. 😂

What episode is that? Dont think it’s in the umbara arc or the ryloth arc

Yeah, they were half a grain (32mg in modern units) each. Just one is a massive dose - 20mg is often considered the maximum safe dose these days. They were young, fit soldiers so could probably handle a bit more, but a single syrette should have been plenty.

​@thomasdalton1508exactly, one is more than enough. 2 and this mf's heart is giving out

Doc was in strike back too.. awesome series

splinter cell reference, in this economy?!

And who’s ever in charge of the range

You know crap is bad when the E4 speaks up😅

And he SURVIVED that shit! Like HOW?!

@thomasdalton1508 ''modern units'' jesus americans will really do anything to avoid accepting they were wrong xD

it's called metric, it's not new, and you should really look into it xD

I'm a medic in Finnish Army Reserv and I too would give such lecture to anyone right here. Medics have the right to speak past ranks as it's crucial to our line of work.

Also there's some useful tools to change officers minds, at least over here in Finland us medics have the right to order ANYONE we suspect that might be suffering a heat stroke to pull their pants down and assume "the receiving position" for core temperature reading RIGHT ON THE SPOT. Needles to say that's a very nifty method to persuade anyone into nearly anything. 😂

​@Lionforge1 he survived but permenantly walked with a limp and parts of his body hurts during cold weather. The bullets dont go through the body cleanly. It stays inside

Being raised around guns is different than being in a warzone and have to be on constant alert. I own a handgun and i live in an open-carry state. But i leave it at home coz i dont wanna accidentally shoot a black kid just coz he is approaching me

​@SHADOW_MOON_878 Depends on the round's construction and how fast it's travelling but yeah usually there is a measure of fragmentation
That he survived at all is a miracle in and of itself. I've killed alot of things with a .30-06 and most of them has been significantly larger than humans. It's a devastating round

Lt Moose Heyliger was no butter bar. He was disciplined, was a good tactician and trusted his NCOs. When Captain Richard Winters was moved up to Battalion CO, he actually recommended Lt Heyliger to take over as Company CO. But he was shot in this scene, and the company was assigned an incompetent Captain from another unit

@SHADOW_MOON_878dude…..what a wild statement…..be less racist

​@ashenmoonclashsome E4s gotta be E8s😂

​@Lionforge1 to be fair, the elk healthcare system is woefully underfunded.

@thomasdalton1508 if im already dying then go ahead 😂

​@JackRogers-x9e Even if we're going for a doctrine of double effect dosage, I'm not sure you would need three syrettes!

​@tradtke101 No bucks for Bucks 😢 🦌💸🏨

And in fairly good lighting too! And trying to respond in English! Yeah the scene doesn't sell "panic" well

​@ironwallaby8189 I mean appreciate his honestly, and unfortunately with the direction African American crime culture has been going I can't blame the guy.

​@Frostguard1 Yep, he's not wrong. 14 percent of the population commit 70% or more of all violent crimes. Gov. George Wallace was right about them.

You may have been to Wyoming, but you've never been to war.

Well, allow me to enlighten you. In MP school in 1982 they trained us to use the word HALT. And then go from there.

Yep sure can. Because he's the **** who's gonna save your life

Depends on where he got hit. You can get hurt bad and still survive I'm a paramedic we once had a guy in my ambulance that got took took 4 four in the torso area with a 45 automatic Eight weeks later he walked out of the hospital

No they're not. I was a for twenty 1 years the United States Navy AKA hospital corpsman I once told a Marine Colonel to shut the **** **** and get out of my get out of my 8 You know what he did just that. If you ain't helping or you're screwing up and I've gotta take care of a patient I pay no slack to anybody That includes you Wellington If you ain't working if you ain't fixing get the hell out of my way

No you would have kept your mouth shut. In the field as a medic they're in charge. And if you had said anything to me at all me you and the regimental commander would have had a chat But I guarantee you the regret of a commander would have sided with me if you're not in the way if you're in the way and you ain't helping if the Met if Doc tells you move you move. So if you got a problem with that maybe you shouldn't be in my unit. I'm also the same way when it comes to being a civil paramedic if you ain't helping or anything like that if you're just if you're just standing around being stupid and I'm working I ain't got time for you

Doctor and logistics officer, no ammo is no ammo.

Pretty sure they'd have had the basics of "don't give morphine to someone bleeding out"

There was never a enlisted pay grade 10 (E10)

@Joe25451 ...that's the joke. It means that when it comes to their job, they outrank EVERYONE.

"How dare you point out my incompetency. There will be consequences, I tell you!" With any luck the doc could spare some time to mend your feelings and splint your fragile ego.

should have been Rotten Tomatoes score of 115%. The best series EVER

​@GaldirEonaivery true...

​@Joe25451I'm not sure if you were in the military but a medic speaks up during a combat setting even a 4 star shuts up.

>When eurodivergents use a dramatized TV scene to denigrate actual people.

That's supposed to be moonlight. It's brighter than reality so we can see it.

Nah. Their body language is pretty clear. "we fucked up, didn't we". They know he's right and it stings.

3
Leg, hip, & shoulder
Woof, those aren't light bullets either, unless by some miracle that bone structure is gonna be devastated

@stephencronin1080
It's common knowledge that when impaled with something, the last thing you do is pull it out. But people panic and do just that.
That's the thing about panic; it erases intelligence.

​@WarpigA23true. Though there's a similar type of friendly fire scene in the Pacific, and I think the pacing and camera angles work better for it

Doc gets a free pass 😂😂

Literally any soldier will tell you that

@AlphaAurora you haven’t been to war how would you know

@drammerrr by chugging lots and lots of monster energy and dip to stay drugged and awake while on sentry duty, duh

Yeah. Suffered some lasting issues (and got a medical discharge due to them) but made it to a pretty decent age (85).

Super nervous sentry (replacement on his first night on watch) calls to them for the password. Both _officers_ apparently forgot it and try "hey you know it's us" but before they can get halfway through the kid panics (these two indistinct figures aren't giving him the password!) and shoots. Then they start yelling in english and it dawns on the kid that he fucked up.

That's the show's version at least. Going by the accounts of people who were there the sentry was an experienced veteran rather than a fresh replacement, which puts the incident in a slightly different light.

According to Winters the real guy was an experienced veteran rather than a fresh replacement, and he had him transferred out of the unit after the incident.

​@GaldirEonai
Huh. I don't know I feel that's worse. Fresh greenie, okay it's a fucked situation, but guy's new. I can see a legit defense from either nerves or lack of knowledge of protocols. But a vet? Mm, that kinda makes the fuck up feel THAT MUCH WORSE.

@Dino-k8i7t Depends on what the guy's been through.

​@stephencronin1080its not they gave morphine to him but more of the fact they dont remember how much they gave him. If they know much morphine is in his blood system they can put enough without killing him.

@seppukumouse8005 Exactly. They all have training on what to do when someone gets hit. Give them the morphine. Put the surette on his jacket so the medic knows how much is in the patient. They're officers. They're grownups. They ought to know better.

​@Dino-k8i7t someone who's been going through it a while might know how to do things but trauma is trauma. His nerves could have been shot, who knows how long he'd been operating, there's a reason you rotate people out and sometimes that isnt enough. Soldiers are still human, mistakes can and will happen and doubly so if you run people hard.

Best thing to do is what winters did, rotate him out. Hopefully put word in to get him sent home, honorably, he did his bit but he's wearing out.

​@WandaIIthats hilarious😂

Who cares

Docs on duty can yell at the president himself for getting in their way.

Any officer trying to pull rank on a doc for doing doc things is going to very quickly have his behavior corrected. Medics may formally exist within the traditional rank structure, but in practice, they cease to exist in that rank structure when carrying out their duties.

If they're just going about general soldierly duties, that's one thing. But medics are such a specialized knowledge and skill set with such high risks that really only other medics can boss them around when it comes to medical care of troops.

So, no. You wouldn't have threatened doc with consequences. You would have said: "Understood doc, my mistake. I won't make it again, doc."

​@ImrightYourewrong-gs4pz
Well, the more intelligent amongst us are impressed by the acting ability of people from other countries. Does it ruffle your red and white striped feathers that Americans were not chosen for the roles.

Isn't a Captain an O-2?

Well I mean it's easier to hit something when it isn't moving. Makes sense.

@Dino-k8i7t ptsd and fear

Police yell freeze, military yells halt.

Yell freeze to someone who isn't American they are just going to be confused. Police in America yell freeze, military yells halt.

It's almost like 'Halt' is a word in both the English and German languages and used by both militaries...

After the war, he became a cop.

General Thomas 'Stonewall' Jackson was shot by his own men who fired immediately after issuing their challenge, and when his staff yelled at them to cease fire; the officer commanding the sentries screamed 'It's a damned Yankee trick! Fire!' And Jackson was hit three times. The officer was convinced it was an attacking Union cavalry force, seeing a squadron of cavalry where there were only a few men.

Contrast with General Nathan Bedford Forrest who accidentally rode into the Union lines, and was politely told of his error and pointed in the right direction. He thanked the Yankees, saluted them, and rode to his own camp.

Strange things happen in war.

@GaldirEonai
Even veterans get jumpy.
How much you can call the 101st veterans when they had never seen combat before D-Day and had only fought a handful of times before being withdrawn from Normandy is debatable. If anything, the men who experienced Normandy, returned to England and then were dropped into Holland had even more reason to be jumpy than the replacements; they were aware of the dangers.

Always had a 249 gunner split between me ad the LT. I was one of the lowest ranked guys in the company but had my own callsign and encrypted radio. I absolutely loved being a medic best job I ever had.

@jimmydesouza4375
When it's not moving and isn't making any threatening actions?
Definitely American cop logic.

Dude who played the Dr delivered that line perfectly, even his eyes look like he’s upset.

Aren’t doctors also officers?

@Tweakalottby “doc” they mean medics not doctors. Medics are enlisted members of the military.

​@DomWeaselyou have no clue what you're talking about.

​​@Myuutsuu85Really? You believe that American cops are highly disciplined and only turn to their guns as a last resort? That they don't piss themselves and draw if someone so much as raises their voice in their vacinity?
If you believe that, well maybe you're interested in buying a bridge.

@Nucleotide5313 Captain is O-3, but Winters was an O-4 Major by this point.

​@OptimusWombat He wasn't. He was filling the role of a battalion XO, but was still a captain. He got promoted to major only in March 1945.