"I Have No Confidence In Our CO, Sir." #bandofbrothes #movie

Name: "I Have No Confidence In Our CO, Sir." #bandofbrothes #movie
Uploaded: 2026-10-13T21:06:09+02:00
Duration: 1 min

1,784 views2026/10/13

Movie Tomb

YouTube Channel

👍 0 👎

▶ Open source

1,784 views · 2026/10/13

#shorts #movie #scene
"I Have No Confidence In Our CO, Sir." #bandofbrothes #movie

Welcome to our movie channel, the place where film lovers come together! Here, you’ll find everything from timeless classics to the latest blockbusters, along with hidden gems you might have missed. We don’t just share movies—we dive into their stories, characters, and the magic behind the scenes, giving you a deeper way to enjoy cinema. Whether you’re here to relive old favorites or discover something new, our channel is all about celebrating the art of film. Hit subscribe and join our community of movie fans—you’ll always have something great to watch!

Thank you!

Comments

106

@stephencindrich135YouTube

One of the very toughest moments of being in command. 🇺🇸

👍 1342026/10/13

@middlelin3YouTube

fine I´ll rewatch it again for the 10th time....

👍 4562026/10/13

@nandorkomlodiYouTube

before the conversation started Lipton was smoking out there and Winters askerd: "I didn't know you are smoking" answer: "Me either" - Lol :D
Best movie ever, I was watching all the parts for years when it came to my mind..
Gogo Spears :)

👍 162026/10/13

@ShroomKeppieYouTube

why was there no salute at the end of that conversation?

👍 42026/10/13

@joshd8443YouTube

You do not salute in the field. Thats Sniper bait.

👍 192026/10/13

@stormjin2242YouTube

Why would you salute in theater?

👍 62026/10/13

@LiamOwen1991YouTube

At that moment winters knew lipton was lieutenant material

👍 9702026/10/13

@billkerballol544YouTube

The same reason theypdo not where there rank.

👍 12026/10/13

@gongping908YouTube

There is nothing Winters can do? Nah there are things he can do, he just has to put himself at risk, like Lipton did

👍 162026/10/13

@ericb2501YouTube

Meanwhile, the book & mini-series besmirched the actual life & legacy of Norman Dike! PS-- I read the book, loved & believed it! I watched the series, same thing! However, the more I read & the more videos I watched, the more I realized how innacurate & full of shit BoB was!!

👍 102026/10/14

@Zaneishere11YouTube

Winters was looking at him in total agreement, yet there was nothing he could do. But he saw real combat leadership in lipton

👍 1,3352026/10/14

@yoshizack7737YouTube

I was watching this and then later tonight it got to 50 degrees. Not even close to what they experienced but cold as shit cant even imagine

👍 102026/10/14

@johnjay7822YouTube

Markie Mark Sr

👍 122026/10/14

@IdkwhatsupwithyouYouTube

Yep, innocent heroes like Lt Dike got screwed over by this. Pretty shameful.

👍 02026/10/14

@Gary-l9n3xYouTube

Exactly, the series hasn't aged well. They did blyth dirty.

👍 12026/10/14

@Gary-l9n3xYouTube

@stormjin2242*the field.

👍 02026/10/14

@jenningsrozzell7557YouTube

It sucks, as an enlisted person to HAVE to follow leadership you know as an NCO is, at best, mediocre in their ability. You just hope whatever stupid decision they make only gets themselves killed.

👍 62026/10/14

@eriksfeYouTube

You gotta pump those numbers up 😂

👍 152026/10/14

@XingmeyYouTube

@eriksfe no

👍 02026/10/14

@XingmeyYouTube

that makes it a best movie?
have you seen any other movie?

👍 02026/10/14

@CooleemeeYouTube

Hang Tough Sergeant. What? I mean, good luck.

👍 32026/10/14

@bobbygetsbanned6049YouTube

I absolute hate what they did to Lt Dike, who btw, earned TWO BRONZE STARS! Winters hated Lt Dike, and they relied almost entirely on Winter's account of what happened, so they made Lt Dike look like an incompetent coward, when he's a legit war hero!

👍 72026/10/14

@bobbygetsbanned6049YouTube

This entire part of the story is complete bullshit. Lt Dike earned TWO BRONZE STARS! He was not incompetent and certainly not a coward. But Winters hated Dike, and they relied almost entirely on Winter's account of events, so they made Dike look like an incompetent coward, when he was absolutely neither of those things!

👍 182026/10/14

@terryhasseler5127YouTube

Nice one!

👍 22026/10/14

@bobbygetsbanned6049YouTube

This is bullshit. Lt Dike earned TWO BRONZE STARS! But Winters hated Dike, and they relied almost entirely on his story, so he got them to portray Dike as an incompetent coward, when he's a legit war hero. I hate this part of show for what they did to a full on WW2 war hero just because Winters hated him.

👍 22026/10/14

@bobbygetsbanned6049YouTube

Justice for Lt Dike! Lt Dike earned TWO BRONZE STARS for VALOR in WW2. He was a legitimate war hero, a competent leader, and not a coward. They disparaged him just because Winters worked on the production and he hated Lt Dike.
They disparaged Sobel the same way , who jumped into enemy territory on D Day, and led his men to destroy a machinegun nest.
It makes for good TV, but those men didn't deserve to have their names ran through the mud like that! Especially not calling Dike a coward, when the production crew apparently couldn't even do a little research and find out he was actually a legit war hero.

👍 22026/10/14

@bobbygetsbanned6049YouTube

Exactly, justice for Lt Dike! LT Dike earned TWO BRONZE STARS, for VALOR of all things. He was NOT a coward, and he was not an incompetent leader! I hate how they disparaged him just because Winters worked on the production of the show and hated Lt Dike.

👍 32026/10/14

@bobbygetsbanned6049YouTube

@Gary-l9n3x Blithe apparently was a legitimate mistake they apologized for. I don't think they ever apologized for portraying Dike and Sobel so badly. Sobel parachuted in on D Day and led an assault to take out a machine gun nest, he also was not incompetent.

👍 02026/10/14

@tfirkins6810YouTube

@bobbygetsbanned6049the point is that by this point Dike should have been taken off the line to at the very least company office/command. The show does I agree do a terrible job of showing what Dike has gone through before and during his command of easy company while focusing too much on his negative traits

👍 42026/10/14

@bobbygetsbanned6049YouTube

It's fake, Lt Dike was a war hero who earned two bronze stars. They disparaged his name because Winters hated him. Sobel was also a competent leader, who parachuted in on D Day, and led his men in taking out a machinegun nest.

👍 32026/10/14

@daugterofAbyssYouTube

Please tell me your joking. 50 degrees? Try -10

👍 32026/10/14

@ericb2501YouTube

@bobbygetsbanned6049Exactly!

👍 22026/10/14

@ericb2501YouTube

@bobbygetsbanned6049Exactly

👍 02026/10/14

@bobbygetsbanned6049YouTube

@tfirkins6810This is not true at all. Dike was a competent leader throughout the war! The only reason Dike is portrayed badly is because Winters hated him and Winters worked on the production of the show. There was no point where Dike should have been removed, it was totally fabricated.

👍 12026/10/14

@PsirosYouTube

It was a typo. He forgot to type the other zero. Lol

👍 82026/10/14

@Hungwaylow-42YouTube

Friendly fire fixes a lot of problems.

👍 12026/10/14

@ThebigDaddyLobsterYouTube

Never gets old though

👍 32026/10/14

@scoutbond4251YouTube

It's 50 degrees INSIDE my apartment in the winter, with heaters running. You're soft as 10-ply

👍 02026/10/14

@erwinthedodo9205YouTube

@bobbygetsbanned6049and he was removed from command in real life for the same reasons.

👍 72026/10/14

@joelmclaughlin2558YouTube

@bobbygetsbanned6049 Me thinks you try too hard.

👍 12026/10/14

@joelmclaughlin2558YouTube

Why was Dike hated?

👍 02026/10/14

@timfronimos459YouTube

No american in the nineteen forties used the phrase ," a coffee".
One of several linguistic errors in the band of brothers that shows the actors were not american.
In the 1940s, someone would have said.Can I get you a cup of coffee or simply can I get you some cof.
Damien Lewis is British as well as half the actors playing americans.
There's a few other linguistic errors throughout the series , but it doesn't change the excellence or quality of the storytelling.

👍 32026/10/14

@SME.RetiredYouTube

Know this: Ambrose has been called out for taking liberties in his book and favoring one person’s account while omitting other conflicting accounts.
Now compound that with a movie studio’s liberties to make a great series.
In reality, Winters simply did not like Dyke, so Winter’s opinion is relayed into the plot. Notice how Winters, in interviews, can be sort of a hardass where the actor was soft and gentle. In the series, Dyke is portrayed as freezing up at Foy, but in reality he was shot in the shoulder near the haystack and had to be evacuated out. Conveniently omitted in the series, right? That’s why Spiers was sent in to relieve Dyke.
Winters made calls for Dyke not to return once healed, so Dyke was assigned as an aide to the 101st Div commander, Lt Gen Taylor. Dyke also served in Korea. He retired as a Lieutenant Colonel earning two Bronze stars, but we all know how officers love to award each other medals.
I’m not saying Dyke was good, just citing this as an example of Ambrose only going with Winter’s version.

👍 3432026/10/14

@lukeysharp94YouTube

Only 10th?

👍 12026/10/14

@MeNombreEsEarleYouTube

The 10th Mountain trained at Camp Hale for 3+ years before deployment to Italy in ‘45. Colorado at 10k ft. Often -30 during training and rifle range.

👍 02026/10/14

@hinglemccringleberry1824YouTube

The C.O. was a made man... there was nothing they could do.

👍 32026/10/14

@VillyVil94YouTube

There was nothing winters could do. The C.O. Was a made man and the sgt wasn’t.

👍 1572026/10/14

@movietombrealYouTube

Movie/Series Name: Band of Brothers (2001)
Genre: History/Drama/Action/Adventure/War
Rating: TV-MA
Rotten Tomatoes: 97%
IMDB: 9.4/10

The men of Easy Company, 506th Parachute Infantry Regiment, train for war and fight across Europe during World War II, forging bonds of brotherhood amid the brutal realities of combat.

YOU CAN WATCH THE MOVIE/SERIES BY CHECKING THE CHANNEL BIO.

👍 382026/10/14

@vitsobotka6268YouTube

he did do a thing. He positioned Speirs and his troops close by in reserve - and sent Speirs to support Dyke´s men. And to be fair to Dyke, he was wounded at Foy, so it was obviously difficult for him to give orders

👍 492026/10/14

@Hairyman921YouTube

THAT'S: SHOOTER.. VERY YOUNG..😅

👍 02026/10/14

@robertbrown6531YouTube

His Brother

👍 02026/10/14

@tamaw1995YouTube

I also am not saying that he for sure was good, but someone's legacy could have been ruined by a one-sided retelling.

👍 362026/10/14

@CsetnikkeYouTube

It was a real West Point type shit.We had to sit there and take it.

👍 332026/10/14

@CsetnikkeYouTube

What would be his reason as Battalion XO?
"I think you are incompetent,lieutenant,you are relieved from leading Easy Company."
That's not a good enough reason.

👍 12026/10/14

@bobbygetsbanned6049YouTube

Idk, but I don't think he was hated by anyone except Winters. We don't have his side of the story because he passed away well before the series was made. We do know for a fact he wasn't a coward though, since he got two bronze stars, specifically for Valor. They also disparaged Sobel, who jumped into Normandy on D Day, led his men to take out a machine gun nest, and was a competent leader.

👍 02026/10/14

@connorkeegan3905YouTube

Fun story the origins of fragging was the only way soldiers with absolutely useless commanders would survive, make it look like an accident

👍 142026/10/14

@kevinhill8193YouTube

@Csetnikke10/10

👍 102026/10/14

@pw6790YouTube

Must see

👍 02026/10/14

@vongillanYouTube

Excellent show

👍 02026/10/14

@rughzenwolfYouTube

Here we go boys... The algorithm have given us Band of Brothers this week

👍 92026/10/14

@guyjoslin7682YouTube

There are work arounds but we dont talk about them

👍 32026/10/14

@robbygallettaenterprises8480YouTube

why they didn't continue this show is beyond me

👍 02026/10/14

@frankmontez6853YouTube

Soo this the part where they try to take this village and the co just breaks down ? Then he as executive officer gets Speirs to take over ? maybe not ..

👍 02026/10/14

@petergould9174YouTube

Possibly not in this case BUT in general I would think this is one of the worst scenarios for a leader. Giving orders that you later realize got your men killed for no good reasons.

👍 32026/10/14

@HiVizCamoYouTube

A convo that would never have happened under any circumstances 😅

👍 12026/10/14

@Wes_C279YouTube

"Didn't think id ever do this"

You were part of the group who got rid of sobel my guy 😅

👍 312026/10/14

@nandorkomlodiYouTube

uh yep I saw a few trash during 40 years.... Then let me ask: did you watch the whole series? The whole you know, not ChatGPT summary or some shorts?

So explicitly then for Transformers fans why I think this whole is a good series.
Things are not just explode, and the whole is not about destruction, it is about development.

This series has real story - close to real, it's documented.
The solders talk before each episode is so good!
The movie has man-to-man jokes all around.
BUT it keeps the tension all the way in every episode.
Like in this speach there is a big tension with the possibility of tragedy. More over if the watcher just try to feel what some main character felt in some situations it is great at all.

Correction then:
Best WW2 movie ever.

I hope it is okay for you now :)

👍 02026/10/14

@CMBalkothYouTube

@tamaw1995Like Albert Blithe…A lot of people consider the man a coward without looking at the bigger picture.

👍 332026/10/14

@OshkoshbigoshYouTube

I know it sounds arrogant, but skilless assholes in positions of authority have been my Wolfsbane my entire career. I can't believe how much stress fell off my back when I retired.

👍 12026/10/14

@MrSteve280YouTube

People don't realize the important lesson here that everyone encounters at one time or another. A good series about the razon's edge of good decisions, bad decisions. and the inevitable.

👍 12026/10/14

@dabiggestblunder9177YouTube

You know captain sobel predicted all this

👍 92026/10/14

@ChonoRock1198YouTube

How much more betrayal could sgt Lipton take?

👍 142026/10/15

@CsetnikkeYouTube

@ChonoRock1198It was self-defense,D!The guy jumped at me with a handgrenade in his hands!

👍 82026/10/15

@coombiYouTube

What are youn trying to say?

👍 02026/10/15

@4thforcon426YouTube

Takes guts to dress down another officer to your CO

👍 02026/10/15

@bimlauyomashitobi421YouTube

It was that moment that Winters knew Lipton was varsity athlete material

👍 102026/10/15

@JosephRoberts-v8uYouTube

That's got to have been an agonizing moment for Winters. He doesn't want to lose a single man, and there isn't a thing he can do to prevent their loss.

👍 12026/10/15

@BKennedy-y9hYouTube

" There's a fault in the system Bobby "

👍 02026/10/15

@madlarkin8YouTube

"I did something as 1SG I never imagined doing..."

*refuses a hot cup of coffee on a snowy day*

Truly a terrible and unconscionable act.

👍 02026/10/15

@guaporeturns9472YouTube

In reality Dike earned two bronze stars… but some men questioned his bravery. He retired to Switzerland in 1960 if that’s any indication of what he thought of the country he served. I don’t know what his motivation was but it’s interesting anyway

👍 32026/10/15

@guaporeturns9472YouTube

Yep true.

👍 02026/10/15

@10thstudioYouTube

People are rightly talking about how the portrayal of Dyke wasn't accurate. However, I would like to add something to that. Dyke was added to easy company to get more combat experience and to progress his career. So the men didn't like him because they thought he didn't want to be there and treated the company like a means to an end and made no effort to engage with them. BUT easy company at this point were very close and were known not to be very welcoming to newcomers and replacements so Dyke spent a lot of time at batallion hq with his buddies, which further increased the men's dislike for him.

👍 12026/10/15

@donaldmetz8586YouTube

Sgt Rock?

👍 02026/10/15

@denisemal7027YouTube

I’ve literally watched this over a hundred times

👍 02026/10/15

@johnwilliams9270YouTube

It's an age old axiom the failure of leadership in times of conflict far outweighs any of the rank and file in the field during Vietnam fragging came about as a last step option when all else failed

👍 02026/10/15

@deildegastYouTube

@CMBalkoth Personally, giving that Blithe lived til 1967 and fought in Korea, 3 purple hearts, 3 bronze stars, one silver star, if i were that family i would sue the series for defamation. They did him so bad.

👍 172026/10/15

@echoct506YouTube

@bobbygetsbanned6049 Dike wasn't a coward. He was however sick and wounded at this point. I admit the show didn't emphasize that, but Dike also should not have been in command here. Not that he was incompetent, but as Lipton said "Empty Uniform" because he was not in condition to lead at that time.

👍 12026/10/15

@disgruntledtacYouTube

Lipp was a better commander than most who wore those ranks. He, Winters, and the NCOs of easy company are the kind of leadership warriors pray for.

👍 02026/10/15

@Lotek117YouTube

@deildegastYeah they literally outright slandered a ton of good men!

👍 12026/10/15

@keepsake327YouTube

Dike was dragged by this show. He wasn’t nearly as bad in real life. He had been in combat and won a bronze star. He was battalion staff officer filling a position after the losses from Holland.

👍 32026/10/15

@johnrussell5896YouTube

It'sThe truth you need , the guys that know what they're doing.. spares we need you. Ain't that the truth

👍 02026/10/15

@AnthonyRomero-w8uYouTube

Spoilers got dayum😂

👍 02026/10/15

@420BrickLordYouTube

this is possibly the greatest show ever. I loved every second of it

👍 12026/10/16

@SoonGoneYouTube

Don't they make up a lottery and the CO wins and gets sent home early or something?

👍 02026/10/16

@listrahtesYouTube

Earning medals means nothing . It can but especially higher ranked very often get medals just for being there. Same in Iraq war with ridiccolous medals for complete mental cases. But I also would never trust a hollywood show. So yes maybe he was the opposite of how he was portrayed in the show. HOllywood rarely does get it right.

Imo european war movies are just much superior because they often dont have the need to create these absurd hero characters like Winters in this show

👍 02026/10/16

@guaporeturns9472YouTube

@listrahtes I agree with your take on European war movies being better , but you’re wrong about medals.. they definitely DO mean something. I know lots of people have done lots of heroic shit in warfare and didn’t get medals , but that doesn’t detract from those who did.

👍 12026/10/16

@ririondabeat1YouTube

Winters knew that Lipton was officer material after that.

👍 12026/10/17

@middleclassretireeYouTube

This is one of the reasons I would have never made it in the military, the fact that a green behind the ears lieutenant can override a experienced first sergeant just because the lieutenant came through a rotc program or had 2 years of basket weaving classes at a junior college , no thanks and no wonder fragging was a thing in Vietnam

👍 02026/10/17

@dvnwnd22YouTube

Lipton was probably my favorite paratrooper in the series

👍 02026/10/17

@saltydoctor4033YouTube

Says it like he didnt mutiny before the jump on Normandy cuz of sobel🤣🤣

👍 12026/10/18

@MidTennPewsYouTube

Nor nothing he would have done. He respected Lip.

👍 02026/10/18

@canneddragoonYouTube

the interesting thing is in reality LT dike was a tested combat veteran at this point in the war, he had definetly proven himself as a capable commander but was seriously struggling with traumatic stress.

👍 02026/10/18

@colelawton2939YouTube

Never fucking happened. Dike was phenomenal.

👍 02026/10/19

@forsakenace9577YouTube

For people that don’t know, the Officers corps is too a degree a good ole boy group.

The reason he thought this would be something that he’d never do, is because it’s very frowned upon for an enlisted man (even someone higher up like a first sgt) to speak ill of an officer to another like that.

👍 02026/10/20

@catusmagnusYouTube

Well-played, fine movie... but this part is falsehood. They're setting up audience for a portrayal of LT Dike, which was absolutely not the truth

👍 02026/10/22

@catusmagnusYouTube

yeah but never happened as played

👍 02026/10/22